. . .
Considering what you find above the three small dots, the first two words make a claim. The last three put it in doubt. If I read the question and then go back to the beginning, ‘This art’ no longer sounds as assured as it did a moment before.
On the white 'canvas' there is nothing else to read. I could take the words as a joke: if the work seeks to reveal nothing, why is it asking me a question? But to have a reason for making something is not the same as deciding what it must mean to someone else. I have a reason for putting these words on a canvas. I am less certain what the canvas can do with them.
There is also the matter of where the words are. A sentence printed in an essay gives way to the next sentence. On the canvas, the question ends and there is white. The space gives me no answer. It may give me time to go back to the words, or it may simply be space around a sentence I have already understood. The difference matters to me. I do not want to credit the canvas with an experience it has not made possible.
I deliberately left this work untitled. I have waited until now to say so because I did not want that decision to be the first thing you knew about it. Perhaps you noticed the absence. Perhaps there was no absence for you until I mentioned it.
If you look again, what has changed knowing this about the title? The canvas has not. You may now read its denial of intended significance in the light of a decision I have told you was deliberate. You may find that the words have acquired a tension they did not have before. Or you may find that I have only given you a new idea about the work, and that the work itself has become no more interesting to look at.
Some may consider this is conceptual art. I do not. I consider these ideas about art.
In my creative work I think of its title as part of what I make. The title belongs with the light, colour, forms, sounds, or words through which I work. It gives the viewer a pathway towards one interpretation, not an instruction to arrive at it. Sometimes the title and the image agree. Sometimes there is distance between them.
Not everyone experiences a title as part of an artwork. It is often perceived of as a practical means of referring to something, or a description whose usefulness ends once we know which painting we are looking at. Yet even a title we think of as merely descriptive can change what we see. If I am told that a painting is called *The Distance Between Us*, an interval between two forms may become more conspicuous than either form. I might read that interval as estrangement. Another viewer might see relief: room to breathe. Neither response is prescribed by the title, though both might have been less available without it.
The title might also get in the way. The interval may be more interesting as a disturbance in the painting’s rhythm than as a suggestion about human relations. I can come to feel that the title has misled me, and I can look against it. What I cannot do is choose to see the painting for the first time again, without having read those words.
That is one reason to withhold a title. It can leave me to find what holds my attention before anyone tells me what is supposed to matter. There is a pleasure in that discovery which an apt title, encountered too early, might take away. And a title that helps me understand one aspect of a work does not necessarily make me like it more. It may clarify something I preferred to leave unresolved.
A work I have made is titled "I Will My Heart And Love". My decision was to provide a way to invite those who might otherwise assume certain assumptions about its main focus: a robot. Words for me are important, and very often the only words an audience will read or come to know when encountering an artwork is the its title.
I could have called the canvas above *Untitled*. That would not have been the same decision as leaving it without a title. *Untitled* would have been its public name, and the name itself might have told you what to look for: a work about the practice of withholding a title. Nor would a label saying ‘This work was deliberately left untitled’ have been neutral. It would have asked you to take the omission as an artistic act before you had had the chance to experience it as one.
Not every work labelled *Untitled* has reached us by the same route. An artist may have declined to name it, or may have chosen *Untitled* as its name. A title may have been lost. *Untitled 1* and *Untitled 2*, or *Untitled A* and *Untitled B*, distinguish works and may encourage us to compare them. *Untitled Part 1* does something more: the word ‘Part’ asks us to imagine a whole. And a phrase in parentheses can offer as strong a cue as any conventional title. If I read *Untitled (After the Flood)*, I may begin to look for what remains.
Where the artist says less, others do not necessarily fall silent. The exhibition title may already have told me what the works are about. The room, the neighbouring works, the artist’s reputation, or a paragraph on the wall can guide my attention. Online, the order of a page can do some of the same work. I have made use of that here: by putting the canvas before this account of it, I have arranged an encounter, not removed its frame.
Nor is the absence of a title equally freeing for everyone. A viewer who knows the artist’s earlier work may recognise a change that makes this work startling. Another viewer may have no reason to notice it. A title could offer that second viewer a way in without giving either viewer the last word. In this way naming is an act of hospitality. It is not a duty to make a work easy. It is a way of inviting someone to stay with a difficulty rather than assuming they already know why it matters.
I am wary when art is said to be ‘beyond meaning’. If this means that no sentence can stand in for a painting, I agree. If it means that I should stop asking what makes the painting significant, I do not. A work can be beyond paraphrase without being beyond significance.
Imagine an abstract painting in which a thin line almost meets a dense block of colour. From across the room I may not notice that they do not touch. When I go closer, I see the narrow strip of ground between them. The space I overlooked is now the part of the painting I keep returning to. I may feel a restraint in that near contact; someone else may feel that the arrangement is precarious. We can disagree and still look together. The particular width of the gap, the weight of the colour, and the direction of the line give us something to return to. They do not need to represent anything else.
I would not ask a painting like this to explain itself. I might not want it titled at all. The ambiguity is in something I can attend to. It does not depend on my being told that the painting is open to interpretation.
But there are times when what I bring to a work seems to be doing nearly all the work. That need not be a fault in the art. I may have been inattentive, or brought the wrong expectations, or wanted a kind of experience the work had no reason to offer. Any judgment ought to begin with looking: what is here, what changes as I stay with it, and what resists the reading I am inclined to give it? If I still find little in the work that sustains or unsettles my response, I do not think the freedom to imagine more is proof of depth. The work may be leaving the interpretation to me rather than giving me something that no single interpretation could exhaust.
What troubles me is not the word 'Untitled' itself. It is the possibility that withholding a name becomes a way of avoiding a decision that might have given the work more to offer. A title need not tell me what to think. It might introduce a memory, a relationship, or a question that changes my encounter with what is already there. When such a possibility is set aside, the work may gain freedom, but it may also lose a connection the artist could have made.
My personal response when encountering works deliberately named 'Untitled' is often of disappointment, and scepticism. Disappointment that the artist failed to use the opportunity of providing a pathway into the work, and scepticism that they have felt or thought carefully about it. I know my response may be flawed, yet that does not prevent my response which leaves me less likely to return to the work, and therefore, less likely in future to be enriched by it.
As I have written, in my own visual work, a title is often part of what makes the work whole. To leave this canvas without one is therefore not a neutral choice for me. I am setting aside a means of expression I ordinarily rely upon, and asking what, if anything, the work gains in return.
In the work created for this essay the words deny intended significance and say the work does not seek to reveal. I, the artist, have nevertheless made it deliberately and I want it to prompt thought. A viewer may find significance in the regardless of what was intended.
A title can also close a door. It may ask me to look for something I cannot find, or make a connection that feels less alive than the one I had begun to form. Hospitality is not guaranteed by naming. The question is what this particular title offers, and what it leaves room for.
I have argued elsewhere that an idea can be compelling without being a crafted artwork. I cannot exempt this canvas because it gives me a question I want to ask. If the white serves only to set off the words, and the words do no more than they do in the opening lines of this essay, then putting them on a canvas may add little. The essay may be the more substantial thing I have made.
Yet a sentence can change when it occupies a surface we stand before. Its size, its position, how close we have to come to read it, and what is left around it are not incidental if they alter the encounter. I want to find out whether the words and the white ground can make the question linger in a way the argument does not. That is a matter for the making and the looking. It is not something I can settle by explaining my intention.
I believe a title can be part of an artwork, and that taking it away can cost the work something. In this instance, I am willing to risk the loss. I wanted you to meet the question before I told you about the omission. Now that you know, you can look again, but not for the first time.
A work may be open because it has many possible meanings. It may be significant without needing to be translated into a message. It may be unrewarding to a particular viewer, even after attentive looking.
I am interested in what my telling has made visible. I am just as interested in what was there to see before I said anything, and in whether a title might have offered something the work cannot offer alone.